The SEC is off to a blazing start. Entering Monday, the league is 53-6 overall, with only six of its 16 programs having lost a game. Seven teams sit comfortably in the AP Top 25, and everyone knows who’s at the top. Florida is No. 1 and hasn’t given anyone a reason to question it. The harder question is who deserves to be behind the Gators. Texas is the highest-ranked challenger at No. 7, but some of the league’s top numbers belong to teams ranked well below that. With a few preseason names having already stumbled, who’s the real No. 2?
The standard: No. 1 Florida
Florida opened the year as the preseason No. 1 for the first time since 2006, even with a Round of 32 exit last season. The Gators do in fact look the part. They beat No. 14 Miami 77-67 in their opener and held off Florida State 81-72 in Tallahassee behind a 21-point double-double from Thomas Haugh. Florida is 4-0, allowing only 62.5 points a game. Keep in mind, this is with the toughest schedule in the SEC, according to Sports-Reference’s strength-of-schedule ratings. That matters, because a lot of the league’s early numbers come from beating up on far softer competition. Florida’s resume is the real thing.
The paper favorite: No. 7 Texas
Texas has the most eye-catching numbers in all the land. The Longhorns are averaging 93.8 points a night while holding opponents to 60.8, and they rank among the national leaders in offensive rating. Center Matas Vokietaitis is averaging 19.5 points per game on 78.4 percent shooting (29-for-37), and freshman Joe Sterling has hit 11 of his 17 threes. But stats can be deceiving. Texas opened with blowout wins over Chicago State, Gardner-Webb and Grambling by an average of 43 points, then scraped by Baylor 75-72 on Sunday. Sports-Reference ranks its schedule 253rd out of 364 teams. With Sean Miller bringing back just 13 percent of last year’s minutes, this group is still a mystery. We will know more about this team after they face Georgetown in San Diego on Nov. 26, their next real test.
My resume pick: No. 22 Vanderbilt
If you factor in numbers more than the poll does, I’d recommend taking a look at the team over in Nashville. The Commodores are 4-0 with the 10th-best SRS in the country, a rating that blends scoring margin and schedule strength, and they’ve done it with an above-average schedule. Wins against Wake Forest 74-51 and Memphis 105-81 have them in great standing. Ace Glass is averaging 17.5 points and is hitting 43 percent of his threes, while Tyler Tanner leads the league with 13 steals. The defense is just the cherry on top, with opponents shooting 23 percent from three, 14th-best in the country. Mark Byington returned only a quarter of last year’s minutes, making the Commodores’ start even more impressive. Texas A&M deserves mentioning too. The Aggies are 4-0 with the second-best SRS in the league and aren’t even ranked in the Top 25.
Not passing the eye test yet: No. 11 Tennessee and No. 18 Alabama
Tennessee is No. 11, but the numbers haven’t caught up just yet. The Vols are 3-0 and beat Tennessee State by only five points on Friday. Their strength of schedule ranks 340th nationally, and their offensive rating ranks 182nd. Could this be a result of Rick Barnes bringing back less than 10 percent of last year’s minutes? A matchup against No. 5 Michigan State on Tuesday will tell us plenty. Alabama, the No. 18 team, is more interesting. The Crimson Tide are 4-0, averaging 97 points a game, and lead the nation with 56 made threes. The problem is on the other end. Opponents are scoring 76 points a game against them, with Nate Oats’ team having to hold off Seton Hall 82-76 on Friday.
Teams with warning signs: Kentucky and Arkansas
Kentucky was No. 24 when it lost 89-69 to No. 15 Kansas in the Champions Classic on Tuesday and then needed an Alex Wilkins 3-pointer with only 2.1 seconds left to beat Northern Arizona 78-77, with “Fire Mark Pope” chants reportedly in the air. The Wildcats are allowing 112.1 points per 100 possessions so far, the worst in the SEC. Arkansas, the No. 12 team in the preseason poll, suffered its first loss of the season, 91-72 to No. 9 Virginia, and fell seven spots to No. 19. The Razorbacks have won two straight games since then, but a roster this new needs time to gel.
Small samples, big questions
It’s still early. Most SEC teams have only played three or four games, mostly against opponents they were heavily favored to beat. Every number above is inflated due to teams scheduling weaker opponents, so we won’t know much until conference play rolls around. LSU and Ole Miss both have net ratings north of +50, but neither has played a schedule that tells us what type of team they really are. Even the SEC’s 53-6 record is mostly built against teams like Gardner-Webb and Oakland. Until we get into the heart of conference play, any rankings you see are simply a rough draft.
My verdict
My pick for the real No. 2 of the conference is Vanderbilt. The Commodores have a top-10 SRS in the country, wins over Wake Forest and Memphis by a combined 47 points, all with a positive schedule rating. Texas may have flashier numbers, but they don’t have a schedule like Vanderbilt’s. Things get interesting quickly. Vanderbilt gets UCF on Nov. 20 and Ohio State on Nov. 24. Texas faces Georgetown on Nov. 26 and Louisville on Dec. 1. If both get past those stretches, this may be a different conversation. Who is your second-best team behind Florida?











